Oversight

-
According to Ofgem on the topic of 'Oversight'. Under the ECO (Energy company obligation scheme the installer must be registered with a certification body.
You can try contacting the National Insulation Association which has procedures for complaints against registered members.  You can also search on the  Green Deal Oversight & Registration Body website where you may be able to find details of your installers’ certification body.   

The National Insulation Association have a rudimentary, often poorly written website which doesn't tell us who the  board members are but does give us useful unbiased information such as :


or the delightful :
I reported the former statement to the BBA.
Update 27/11. BBA replied that it is stated in individual certificates under "Durability" which when I checked on some certificates is true that it says that the insulating properties of the material should last the life time of the building. But as far as I know the BBA do not test a product under real world conditions for e.g a decade or more and certainly not the 25 years that CIGA guarantee for.

If we look at the past directorship of the National Insulation Association. Aside from the fact that the majority of the directors seem to be from the industry as per CIGA, you will also see that it's hard to separate CIGA from the NIA because so many CIGA members have or do serve on the board of NIA.
We already know that CIGA board members have potential conflicts of interest when it comes to investigating and reporting on CWI failures and due the similar makeup this potential naturally extends to the NIA.
NIA have their own complaints procedure which involves mediation by the NIA against an installer (even though the installer could easily be affiliated with an NIA director) and a the NIA board can then review if mediation fails. I could not find any information on the NIA site about who the board members are.
I have not had any dealing with NIA because my installer and system designer has gone bust and so it defaults to CIGA to handle the 'concern'. But looking from the outside, surely for Ofgem to state that NIA is an oversight body is a grave oversight in itself.
Here is a list of directors of the NIA past and present according to companies house as of 22/11/2018 and their affiliation to CIGA.
Past/present DirectorCurrent or past CIGA Relationship
CLAYTON, Martin William

DEATHRIDGE, Timothy Leslie James 

EASDON, Michael James

HORROCKS, Derek Ian

MOLLARD, Ian Langford

RALPH, NickCIGA Director. Rockwool executive
ROBSON, David Fairfax CIGA director, instagroup director
ALLDER, Gillian Ann

MARSHALL, Neil

A & M INSULATIONS LIMITED

COMISKEY, Fergus

CORONET INSULATION SERVICES

COSYCOAT INSULATION LTD

COSYHOME INSULATION LIMITED

DEANCROFT HOUSE

DOMESTIC & GENERAL INSULATION SERVICES LIMITED

DONALD, NeilCIGA Director and also co director at Miller Pattison with CIGA board member Michael Dyson
DOUGLAS, Alan Stewart

DUKE, Steve

ECOMAX (UK) LTD

EXECUTIVE INSULATION (MIDLANDS) LTD

FRENCH, Walter NewmanCIGA Director 
HARDIMAN, Anthony CIGA director, chair of CIGACIGA Director 
HOPKINSON, Ian ColinCIGA Director 
INSTAFOAM & FIBRE LTDROBSON, David Fairfax, Jeremy John Fairfax directors of instagroup and current and past CIGA board members.
INSUWALL LTD

KERSHAW CONTRACTING SERVICES LIMITED

L R BURROWS & CO LIMITED

LAWRENCE, David AndrewDirector THE SOLID WALL INSULATION GUARANTEE AGENCY , 
MARK INSULATIONS LTD



MILLER PATTISON LTDLinks to CIGA as above and Michael Dyson shares directorship with CIGA
Michael John DYSONCIGA Director 
MOLLARD, Keith ErnestCIGA Director 
OWENS CORNING BUILDING PRODUCTS UK LIMITED

ROBSON, Jeremy John FairfaxCIGA Director  insta group
ROCKWOOL LTDRALPH Nicholas director of CIGA and Rockwool executive
SCOTT, Lorraine

SMITH, Robert Christopher

TEBB, Andrew GrahamPolyperl director with Ian TEBB who is a CIGA director (presumably related)
TEBWAY (TRENTSIDE) LIMITEDIAN TEBB CIGA director
WEST ANGLIA INSULATION LTD

WHITEWOOL LTD


It's probably not complete as CH website not the easiest to search and some people are listed differently e.g a middle initial on one company and without on another which makes them appear as 2 different people.
The ofgem site also gives a link to Green Deal certification bodies. I'm not sure how useful it is as it lists BBA, CIGA, The National Insulation Association and a few others who I've not had the time yet to look at their role.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The controversy over Cavity Wall Insulation 'topups'

-
Image
In this article I talk about the practice and problems of topping up insulation when voids are discovered, why it is being done and the potential violations of building regulations. I can only put forwards what I have understood from public documents and personal correspondence  So I welcome corrections or clarifications from the industry on this important issue for home owners and will happily update this post to reflect any inaccurate statements. We know that 100s of topups are done every year.   From what I can gather : If the BBA have not approved these topups then the relevant local authority building control should have been notified prior to topping up as an 'off licence' use of the product.  It is not clear that the correct procedures are being followed in all cases. Background :Voids are common A void is simply an area cavity between the walls which is missing insulation.  If a void is large enough then the insulation will not be compliant with the meter square
Read more

Discrepancies between Internal and external DPC (damp proof course)

-
Image
In a cavity wall construction, one would expect that the damp proof membrane to be at the same level on both walls. It turns out this is not always the case and my house is a good example where the internal wall's DPC is more than a brick lower than the external wall DPC. I didn't even think to check this before reading the CIGA Technical note 14 . This clearly states that if the distance between DPC and ground level is within a brick (as was the case with my property at time of install) then 'numerous other factors' must be assessed before declaring the dwelling as being suitable for CWI. CIGA  Technical note 14 . One of the factors is the relative level of the inner and outer leaf DPC. This is exactly what I found in my property. Ive used a floorboard to show the position of the internal floor. The DPC is clearly a brick below the floorboard and less than brick above the block paving. External leaf DPC is 1 brick below the floor level.
Read more

CWI, Impermeable masonry paint, hard cement and breathability

-
Image
Waterproof or let's call it plastic masonry paint made with silicone or acrylic sounds like a fantastic idea to keep that pesky rain away from the wall. Unfortunately it can easily cause the opposite in terms of moisture management and inflict devastating damage to old solid walls which were originally made with a breathable building envelope. This article serves as a discussion to highlight some of the unexpected problems which show up in the real world verses the limited testing of the BBA certificates and I welcome discussion from anyone interested in this subject. For a good 'primer' on the problems associated with plastic paint in solid walls, Peter Ward from Heritage House has a number of videos of detailing the sacrilege caused by often well meaning tradesmen applying these aggressively marketed products. I recommend watching all his videos especially if you are having any sort of damp problems so that you can avoid the multimillion pound interventions sold by 
Read more